Forums / Public / General discussion / Self-help books as a gift? Good or Bad Idea? What would you do?
| Author | Message |
Power2Frogs
6 posts |
#15 2007-06-04 13:58 GMT |
|
I imagine I'm not alone in saying that most of my family members are simply "a mess". I swear I was switched at birth. Regardless, this doesn't stop me from feeling this sense of obligation to them to help them progress successfully through their various situations. However, I know they have to WALK THE WALK themselves, because no amount of advise I gave them (which they asked for) has EVER worked. So, many months ago I stopped giving advise or listening the drama.. completely. It saddens me that they're so lost.
Recently I found some good, short, self-help books by AC Ping and while reading through them I kept thinking about my family and how I wished they could understand how they are perpetuating the negativity and stagnation that IS their lives. So I wonder, would you give a self-help book to a loved one? Do you think most people would be insulted? Also, if someone is unable to see that they need to change, do you think it would do them any good anyway? I guess I did leave out some important info... The books are titled: BE and DO. I read through one in a couple hours. They aren't badgering or demeaning and they aren't about any specific thing that one needs to "do better". They are about life in general and about asking yourself important questions about who you are and who you want to be... I think of them as more motivational books; however, they are filed as self-help. |
|
Grimmy
8 posts |
#16 2007-06-04 14:03 GMT |
|
They will not change except on their own, and not very likely. They might be insulted, but if they take your advice they will always resent you. Its two edged sword. I have been there and done that so it is a matter of what you think is best. Keep them as family or straighten them out, but lose the family.
|
|
HahaYouNoob
10 posts |
#17 2007-06-04 14:03 GMT |
|
Self help books are for people who want to help themselves. If a person does not see the problem, then that person is unable to fix the problem. My advice to you is to just set a good example for them. Try not to be judgemental...giving them a self help book is tantamount to passing judgement.
|
|
Green
10 posts |
#18 2007-06-04 14:05 GMT |
|
it's their fault and that's the truth. don't be scared of telling the truth. they must know it. give the book
|
|
God
9 posts |
#19 2007-06-04 14:06 GMT |
|
Personally, I'd be pretty insulted if I recieved a self-help book that was titled something like, "How-to improve your crappy personality." Since the titles of the gifts in question might be a little bit more vague, your family might not immediately find them insulting. If I recieved a self-help book that urged me to immediately change my personality, I'd definitely be insulted by the giver; the person obviously doesn't like the person that I am. If it, however, urges me to think independently and to be myself and love that person, then I would likely be flattered and take initiative.
The best way to GIVE a gift of that nature would be to direct it towards yourself. "I read this book and it really changed my perspective on _____" or "This book was so interesting, I never knew how much my nose-picking was a sign of obsessive-compulsive disorder!" It also depends on how close you are to these people; if they are very close, they are likely to see the gift as something worthwhile and a sign that you care. Others might not. |
|
Green
10 posts |
#20 2007-06-04 14:22 GMT |
|
Good books are "The seven spiritual laws of success" by Deepak Chopra, And "The road less traveled" trilogy by M. Scott Peck. "Life Strategies", by Dr. Phil is truly a winner. These books are nice gifts and can really help to unravel "messy" people's lives. Yeah, people need to be willing so just pray for them and give them these books out of love. The number one best selling book is The Holy Bible. Way better than self help... but they can all lead to happier, more productive, more organized lives. Those other three books that I mentioned are actually written by people who Oprah deems as three of the greatest people she knows. And she's pretty smart. good luck.
|
|
> 1 <
supermarket exhale effort balance sales photo physically smaller affirmations month beneficial mindset free speech place d event common after psychotherapy facility adware contentment teacher avoid properly dysfunction service happy finish us breath security soul civ vision perform cuff radio memory result worksheet work find money love obey seminar choices viruses hold
Categories: Make Life Long Friends Overcoming Fear Relaxation Overcoming Shyness Vision Board Self Defense Tips Get Organized Gratitude Memory Changing your Life Positively Life Saving Strategies Personal Development Sleep And How To Rest Better The Power of Positive Thinking Speed Reading Improve Yourself Dating & Relationships Ten Ways to Change Your Life Learn Chinese Hypnosis Feng Shui Anger Self Improvement Subliminal Tapes Business Self Starters Coaching Programs Today Popular Marketplace Items Self Improvement with Yoga Brain Juicer Brainstorming Breaking Bad Habits Self-Help Success Tips Shared Road To Success Self-Defense For Women Tatoos Law Of Attraction Positive Self Talk Personal Development Time Management Tips Eliminating Stress & Anxiety Manage Time Create More Time Procrastination Self Improvement Therapy Self Development Losing Weight Overcoming Fear Of Spiders Law Of Attraction Getting A Life Time Management Stress Management Self Confidence Self Improvement Self Esteem Positive Thinking Motivation Life Coach Leadership Development Happiness Goal Setting Emotional Intelligence Creativity Communication Skills Anger Management Public Speaking






